Printing a Post - Diagnosing and Rehab of Back Pain -
Select "print" from your browser's "File" menu.

Back to Post


Display Name Post: Diagnosing and Rehab of Back Pain
Wicked Willie
The mouth of the South
Posts 16864
Wicked Willie
02-11-06 08:18 AM - Post#183944    

If anybody has had similar experiences or wishes to offer serious advice...I'm all ears.

Had one of "those" back spasms this morning. Bent down (with bended knees, of course) to pick up a clothespin that one of the cats was batting around. I took a painful shot in the left lower back, just below where my lat attaches.

Drove me to my knees and forced me to become immobile...pain was very sharp, stinging and it came in waves...the type of pain that you try everything in your power to get away from...but you can't. After what seemed like an eternity (actually about 45 seconds, I'd say) the pain eased up enough to let me stand.

Starr seems to think these are generated by muscle strength imbalance between the abs and lumbars...plus a lack of stretching. I probably have both conditions in abundance. The various limb length and muscle issues from cerebral palsy don't help the matter, either.

Anyone else experience these...and what do YOU do to handle them?

I haven't had one for over nine months...thought I was doing well.

Wicked
"I'm in good shape for the shape I'm in."

"Jesus said to him, I am the way, the truth, and the life:
no man comes to the Father, but by me." John 14:6

cajinjohn
Old time trainer
Posts 12495
cajinjohn
02-11-06 10:20 AM - Post#183945    

I keep that at bay by doing hyper ext. and rope tucks. equal amount for both. Goes back to that old push-pull same amount of reps.
It don't matter

Hack
'The Standard remains the Standard"
Posts 4182
Hack
02-11-06 10:21 AM - Post#183946    

Let the cat have the clothespin. A buddy at my gym was saying his back spasms often enough that if he sees anything less than folding money on the ground he passes by without attempting to pick it up. Me, I walk behind him.

As you get older it is harder to have heroes, but it is sort of necessary.
Ernest Hemingway



J G
Old hand here on IOL
Posts 510
J G
02-11-06 10:44 AM - Post#183947    

Willie,

An orthopedic surgeon told me that these things don't happen from just one thing (ie; picking up the clothespin). It is the result of a lot of insults you have perpetrated on your back. (thus the expression "the straw that broke the camel's back).

Now that you have it, the only thing I can suggest that is of any help is ice it during the first 24 hrs then use heat after that. Last year I used those ThermaCare heat wraps. They seemed to help better than a heating pad. Take anti inflammitories and make sure you get up and walk around at regular inervals (maybe every hour).

Once you get better, try to implement a more complete stretching routine and do lots of warm ups (you should be sweating)before you work out.

I used to get those on a regular basis and havent had one for almost 5 years (I hope I just didn't jinx myself because we are getting a foot of snow tonite).

Good luck,

John G.
SGT Snorkel
Old, fat, and ugly
Posts 260
SGT Snorkel
02-11-06 12:21 PM - Post#183948    

A monthly trip to the chiropractor keeps the biggest problems at bay. I still get pulls/strains periodically, but that is due to my dyslexia. My age is 52, but I try to act 25 in the gym.

I always find light weights lightly exercising the muscles that are hurting seems to help.
Always glad to share my ignorance - I've got plenty. Time is a great healer but it is a lousy beautician.

brucedl
Grand Pooh-Bah
Posts 2406
brucedl
02-11-06 12:58 PM - Post#183949    

WW,
I'm with CajinJohn a 100%. Before I did hypers and lots of ab work, I would periodicly get spasms in my back like you. After sticking to the hypers, etc. no more spasms. For now motrin, ice and rest.

Hope your better soon.

Bruce
TomS
Old hand here on IOL
Posts 295
TomS
02-11-06 01:10 PM - Post#183950    

Wicked,
I have been there soooooooo many times. I have had minimal problems
since I have been stretching religiously. I agree with icing it down...
Motrin...walking...
Take time to review "Stretching" by Bob Anderson. I dust off my copy every
few months and review.
Hang in there...
TomS "Friends come and they go...but 200 lbs. will always be 200 lbs." - Dave Draper "Work as if you don't need the money, Love as if you have never been hurt and Dance as if nobody is watching!" - KK

archer45
At home here
Posts 213
archer45
02-11-06 04:24 PM - Post#183951    

hey WW -- don't forget to keep your potassium and magnesium up, a lack of each/either can contribute to muscle spasms -- just a thought, the others have you covered on rest -- good luck
Jim Bryan
Been there, done it.
Posts 380
Jim Bryan
02-12-06 08:41 AM - Post#183952    

****Wicked,
I have been there soooooooo many times. I have had minimal problems
since I have been stretching religiously. I agree with icing it down...
Motrin...walking...
Take time to review "Stretching" by Bob Anderson. I dust off my copy every
few months and review.
Hang in there...

--------------------
TomS***

***Willie,

An orthopedic surgeon told me that these things don't happen from just one thing (ie; picking up the clothespin). It is the result of a lot of insults you have perpetrated on your back. (thus the expression "the straw that broke the camel's back).

Now that you have it, the only thing I can suggest that is of any help is ice it during the first 24 hrs then use heat after that. Last year I used those ThermaCare heat wraps. They seemed to help better than a heating pad. Take anti inflammitories and make sure you get up and walk around at regular inervals (maybe every hour).

Once you get better, try to implement a more complete stretching routine and do lots of warm ups (you should be sweating)before you work out.

I used to get those on a regular basis and havent had one for almost 5 years (I hope I just didn't jinx myself because we are getting a foot of snow tonite).

Good luck,

John G.***

GOOD advice!
Jim Bryan

Wicked Willie
The mouth of the South
Posts 16864
Wicked Willie
02-12-06 08:56 AM - Post#183953    

I agree with the "multiple small insults" line of thought.

I usually start experiencing these when I reach a certain strength level...unfortunately, I think the leverage squats are the "final straw" culprit. Am going to try a stiff sheet of plywood under my side of the mattress, also.

This morning, I had another attack just after getting out of bed. Makes for an annoying start to your day and the cats look at you funny.

I thought I had these things on the run...but apparently not. Back to square one.

Wicked
"I'm in good shape for the shape I'm in."

"Jesus said to him, I am the way, the truth, and the life:
no man comes to the Father, but by me." John 14:6

ccrow
old hand
Posts 10055
ccrow
02-12-06 10:57 AM - Post#183954    

Willie, sorry to hear you're tweaked. I get similar trouble when I lay off the heavy stuff for a while. I think the hips and legs gain strength faster than the mid and upper back re-learn to stabilize the spine under heavy loads.

The spot you describe sounds like it may not be low-low back. This might make sense as the top of the hip belt is pushing the vertebrae around in an unusual way. It would be very tempting not to lock the core and mid back doing hip belt squats and I could see that happening. Does it seem like the pain could be coming from the lowest ribs getting out of line? If so it could actually be the thoracic vertebrae that's getting you.

For you back:

ICE spasms. Period.

If appropriate, use a muscle relaxant. A small amount of alcohol isn't the worst muscle relaxant in the world and the side effects are usually a known quantity.

Love or hate Paul Chek, but use a SWIS ball to stretch. Just lay on the ball and relax; let your elbows and knees slump towards the floor. An average height man needs a 65 cm ball, taller may need larger.

Use reverse hypers liberally when you can do them pain free. Regular hypers are a close second, but you'll be able to do reverse hypers easier. You can do them on the ball or improvise something.

For the mid back, I use a foam roller, these are a miracle for the mid back. If you can't buy a foam roller locally, tough guys (or desparate for relief guys) can use a 3'-4' section of 4" PVC. Your mid back will pop like a zipper.
The most important test a lifter has to pass
is the test of time.
-Jon Cole

Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
02-12-06 11:50 AM - Post#183955    

I really like the foam roller, too, Byron. And I've been stretching daily for about 15 minutes over the last couple of months and have really become a fan of it (surprised myself!) as a result of the progress in flexibility.

But about the swiss ball, can you design a FRUGAL version? Otherwise, you'll gain no traction over at Wicked's house.

ccrow
old hand
Posts 10055
ccrow
02-12-06 12:05 PM - Post#183956    

I am always up for saving a buck myself. But then, Sam's Club has very good quality, heavy duty ball for $20; you can find cheapos that are perfectly adequate for stretching for $10-$15 at WalMart and K-Mart. So there's not that much to save here. Still it's always good to know how to improvise.

If you have a heavy bag, you can put it up on the edge of a table or something high enough to get your toes off the ground as you lay across it, this works very well for reverse hypers. In a pinch, a duffel bag stuffed with laundry would work.

You can also roll carpet around one of the pins in the power rack, set just over waist high, and fold yourself in half over the pin to do reverse hypers. (Willie's tall so he will be able to reach the other pin with his hands for balance.)
The most important test a lifter has to pass
is the test of time.
-Jon Cole

Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
02-12-06 12:34 PM - Post#183957    

Quote:

ccrow said:
You can also roll carpet around one of the pins in the power rack, set just over waist high, and fold yourself in half over the pin to do reverse hypers. (Willie's tall so he will be able to reach the other pin with his hands for balance.)




I'd love to be around for the first trial run on this one! :~)

Wicked Willie
The mouth of the South
Posts 16864
Wicked Willie
02-12-06 02:29 PM - Post#183958    

I'd like to watch that mine own self.

Have a reverse hyper set up...just trying to secure a sufficiently comfortable way to pad the bench...as it really digs into my hips.

Wicked
"I'm in good shape for the shape I'm in."

"Jesus said to him, I am the way, the truth, and the life:
no man comes to the Father, but by me." John 14:6

ccrow
old hand
Posts 10055
ccrow
02-12-06 05:38 PM - Post#183959    

Laree, the carpet roll was maybe the third wackiest experiment tried at my gym that week :)~ I ought to sell tickets. But, I have gotten up to around 100# reverse hypers with that setup, is good! Nothing like you can do with the real deal, Louie's machine, but still good.

Willie, maybe try one of those yoga mat thingies, one of the nice thick ones, and leave it rolled up, and set it at the end of the reverse hyper. Or the carpet roll, carpet is a good pad. Or, set the board lower in the rack and put the physio ball on the board. For rehab you don't need to add weight, just the weight of your legs is fine.
The most important test a lifter has to pass
is the test of time.
-Jon Cole

irondawg
iron claw
Posts 1999
irondawg
02-13-06 10:49 AM - Post#183960    

I do a lot of sit ups and Hoffman frog kicks and back raises for my back.I have problems with it from time to time thanks to "America's Sport"football.A perfect mattress is essential,I sleep on an air mattress now.Hoffman frog kicks are hanging from a bar and raising you knees up and bending your legs to the point your knees are up to about your chest.And Soma a muscle relaxer I get from the Doctor is helpful,I rarely use it,but it knocks it out pretty quick.
How often has bad management been mistaken for destiny?

Erkmax
How many reps did I do?
Posts 1259
Erkmax
02-14-06 02:10 AM - Post#183961    

I used to get a lot of back spasms when I was squatting. I paid strict attention to my form, being extra careful to not bend my back while doing squats but the spasms used to return anyway every leg day. I found out that my lower back was lagging badly behind in development and that's when I quit squatting and started deadlifting. I have recently returned to the squat rack to find that the lifts are now going up easier.

My deadlifting and the hyperextensions made my back much stronger. The back muscles take the longest to recover so I knew that any strengthening of that area must be done slowly. I now incorporate the lower back in my workouts to keep it strong. The overlap between my leg days and my chest and back days means that I have to be extra careful in my execution of any lower back excercises so as to not push things over the edge and wind up unable to move or train for a week.
Eric -- Erkmax

http://www.fitday.com/WebFit/PublicJournals .html?Owner=erkmax

http://www.myspace.com/erkmax


SOLDIEROFGOD
Seeker of Truth
Posts 419
SOLDIEROFGOD
02-15-06 07:20 PM - Post#183962    

Wicked,
Are you currently seeing a chiropractor? An array of orthopedic tests would pinpoint the exact strength as well as structural/biomechanical imbalances. And he/she may find (hopefully not) any underlying problems of a differant nature. You obviously are very body aware which is good, but seeing a DC can't hurt. Just a thought. Stay well man.


Byron,
I've implemented one of your other methods, the swiss bar on the bench. But you mention 100 lbs, how are you applying resistance in all these scenarios? I'm assuming Wicked's set-up is the one featured in Hardgainer by McRobert, placing a plank along the power rack pins. He also had a welded lead pipe contraption to add weights, what do you do?

Alex

"A person should not believe in an -ism"

Ferris Bueller


All this chitter-chatter, chitter-chatter, chitter-chatter,'bout schmatte, schmatte, schmatte

Elfling
Master trainer
Posts 1133
Elfling
02-15-06 07:32 PM - Post#183963    

Are you applying heat?
ccrow
old hand
Posts 10055
ccrow
02-15-06 07:50 PM - Post#183964    

Alex, to add weight, I cinch a strap (a large dog collar actually) around my ankles, then put a dumbbell between my shins. THe plates on one end of the dumbbell are on my instep, the plates on the other end are behind my heels, and the handle is resting on the belt. That is not a great description but I think you get the idea. I have to set up sitting on a strategically placed bucket so I can stand up and hop on without moving my feet. It sounds harder than it is :)
The most important test a lifter has to pass
is the test of time.
-Jon Cole

Wicked Willie
The mouth of the South
Posts 16864
Wicked Willie
02-15-06 09:35 PM - Post#183965    

Alex:

No, I'm not currently seeing a DC. I've had notoriously poor success with DC's with the notable exception of Corey.

Most ignore what I tell them and just run me through the standard battery of "tests," which really aren't relevant to my condition. One used the "painless activator," which I feel isn't effective.

None but Corey have given me any massage prior to the adjustment...which to my way of thinking is counterproductive and an invitation to injury. Spasming muscles are what pull the spine and other processes out of alignment...just making the adjustment ignores half the problem.

Don't take this personally...it's just a statement of historical fact. If I could live next to Corey and find a good orthopod to write a proper prescription for corrective shoes...I could answer about eighty percent of my current "issues." The other twenty percent is up to me and would require intensive stretching and "active release" techniques.

Thank you for your concern, though.

Here is a picture of my reverse hyper set up. I don't have the pipe pivot for the swing arm...bodyweight has been sufficient thus far.

Wicked
"I'm in good shape for the shape I'm in."

"Jesus said to him, I am the way, the truth, and the life:
no man comes to the Father, but by me." John 14:6

Daveyboy
Starting to like posting
Posts 144
Daveyboy
02-16-06 05:32 AM - Post#183966    

Good mornings using an e-z curl bar wrapped in a towel. gradually increase the weights slowly but progressively 8-15 reps a set.Worked great for my lower back, and has greatly improved my squatting and deadlifting.
DG "Dream As If You'll Live Forever, Live As If You'll Die Today." -- James Dean

brucedl
Grand Pooh-Bah
Posts 2406
brucedl
02-16-06 08:56 AM - Post#183967    

WW,
That's one mean looking piece of equipment!! Have you thought of rounding the edge of the wood where you pivot your body. That might help even with thin padding. Look for shiping carts with high density foam glued in them. Not the foam like you spray in as insulation. Might help to take a drive around some local factories and look though their wood and crates. Asking permission would be good too.

Hope you feel better soon.

Bruce
Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
04-09-06 03:00 PM - Post#199289    

25 years of aggressive and consistent weight training is not enough to compensate for a lifetime of bad posture. You see, my back muscles are as strong as I need, stronger even, yet my back's aching all the time. We're not talking about lack of strength in carrying or pulling, and we're not talking about injury; we're talking about imbalance, lack of flexibility and a weakness in the supportive muscles that hold the body -- the spine and head -- upright.

Don't assume this is a case of exercising wrong, bad form or whatnot. It's more of a case of workload imbalance, heavy deadlifts, say, but offset by only bodyweight hyperextensions, for instance� and these would be hypers with less-than-stellar range of motion, having bought into the "don't extend your back farther than parallel" school of thought. Wrong school, I now believe.

Those who've been around for a few years may remember earlier posts as I discovered Active Release Therapy (ART) to release adhesions in my shoulder, gave in to massage to loosen spasming mid-back muscles, sought out chiropractic to ease a pinched nerve in my neck that caused migraines, and learned upper back isolation exercises to cure an impossibly aching neck.

I had an aching neck and traps for close to 20 years, which worsened the past few as I began spending most of each day in front of the computer. Turns out the rhomboid muscles below the traps were weak, so all the effort of holding up my head went to the neck area. When weakened, my neck locked up completely, causing headaches. A most-excellent chiropractor did aggressive massage on the rhomboids, hooked me up to a Stim machine for a couple sessions and gave me specific, targeted, light-weight, goofy-looking exercises that I did for a month to completely clear up this 20-year problem. Embarrassing, really, to have not known this before.

Here's the post that documented the goofy exercise that began to cure my neck in less than a week.

I wrote in a post a year ago that I grew up kinda stubborn: work hard, ignore pain; see a doc only when bleeding or broken; vitamins are a stupid waste of money. I confused strength with health, and it got me in trouble over the past 10 years. Bigtime. Some of the items on my list were purely physical, like muscles in spasm, adhesions and imbalance that were causing me grief; the others were hormonal deficiencies and imbalances. All are intertwined, and all pain and hormonal problems contribute to a catabolic state (when muscles and body tissue is broken down), as opposed to an anabolic state (when the tissue repair process is healthy). Catabolism and cortisol make you feel awful, worse in the big picture than losing a few pounds, but the combination will surely keep us fatter than we want to be, so perhaps a thought here will help with those last few stubborn pounds, too.

Now, a few months ago I went off on another track. A guy from San Diego, Pete Egoscue, has built a practice around a method of stretching that begins by flattening the lower back to the floor. My thinking at the moment is this was the opposite of what I personally needed, and contributed to making things worse. Or perhaps I was just doing the work wrong.

Here's an excerpt of Pete's book, available at this link on Amazon.com:

This stretching started me on a quest for increased flexibility, so I added more stretching exercises to mix, including stuff like toe-touches, which thrilled me because I went from a lifetime of hitting about mid-shin on my way to my toes, to a solid three fingers on the floor. Bad juju, unfortunately.

To correct this, I read the book, The Stark Reality, by Dr. Steven Stark,> as recommended by both Jim Bryan and Fred Fornicola in Static Stretching here in the forum recently, and discovered pretty much all of my stretching exercises are wrong. Stuff I picked up back in the late '70s from the early Jim Fixx and Runner's World crowd didn't hold up through the year 2006. These stretches didn't bother me those decades ago, but the aging tendons and ligaments didn't stand the excess strain so well this time around.

The basics of Stark's work is to stretch the muscle, not the connective tissue, by isolating the muscle, finding the point of no tension and then moving gently into the first point of tension. Hold there until the tension diminishes, release and repeat. My mistakes were in not isolating the muscle, and in overstretching -- yanking on the tendons instead of gently easing the muscle into its full length. The book explains how the muscles, tendons and ligaments work in a way I'd never seen or known (and will have to review again).

Couple the incorrect stretching with my re-energized cardio work that you may remember (Dave's wrong, right?), which I started doing aggressively on my spin bike. This is done bent over in a bike racer's position, in case you've never seen a spin bike. Upon finishing the biking, I'd get on the floor and to the incorrect stretching, in particular, lots of back flexion stretching� basically, bend over the bike handles, then get on the floor and bend over some more.

This felt good to me, because, as it turns out, that's my strong position. It's the back extension that needs work, so what happened over the past couple of months is my back got worse and worse until eventually -- recently -- I could barely face coming up to sit at my desk. Anything but that! Only� if I don't sit here, nothing gets done.

I did some research, checking out things like herniated discs, arthritis and osteoporsis, and in the midst of it, bumped into the "The McKenzie Method,"basically a combination of back extension exercises that offset weak posture muscles and help to elongate the spine. The example of slouching posture fit me to a T, and it's a posture I've held since I was around twelve -- hopefully all this time invested in perfecting it will be forgotten quickly as I practice Robin's exercises....Robin McKenzie's 7 Steps to a Pain-Free Life, got it for $10.40 at Amazon.

Part of McKenzie's philosophy is that problems arise when we bend forward while lifting or working, etc., and I take issue with that (not that I'm in any position to). Instead, *I* think it's more a matter of building up opposing muscle strength. If this new regime works to any extent, and I'm still able to do my normal lifting of cases of books, lugging them up and down the hill and all, I'll stand by this position, but of course, following up the forward bending with an equal amount of back extension work.

I also got a new backless computer chair ($49 at OfficeMax) that's sort of forcing the issue.

The dense foam roller I picked up a few months ago is getting double use (Dave rolls around on it, too), and the myofascial release ball hurts like the dickens� several times a day.

Clair Davies' Trigger Point Therapy Workbook (picked that one up when Dan Cenidoza posted how valuable it's been to him) is as yet unopened. Haven't tried hanging upside down yet, but I have it on good authority that Dick Tyler, D.C. (Dave's golden era pal who wrote both West Coast Bodybuilding Scene and the text Alternative Chiropractic) inverts himself twice a day to hold together his weak back.

Some of you guys will think I'm nuts right about now. But I got to the point where it was either fix it for real, or back off and accept a future of back pain and I wasn't ready to go that route.

As things progress over the next couple of weeks, I'll add any discoveries. One of the points to note is what a long process this can be, one fix leads to another, or perhaps even causes something adverse. But you have to keep at it. It's either that, or plan on spending the rest of your life on the couch.

Meanwhile, here are links in the wiki that all this back pain research dredged up.

**And later... here's the rehab followup post.
DanMartin
Shomer Shabbos
Posts 20705
DanMartin
04-09-06 03:14 PM - Post#199290    

Swiss ball girlie girl, Swiss ball.
Mark it Zero.

Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
04-09-06 03:50 PM - Post#199291    

Oh, right! Forgot to mention I'd been doing that some at the gym.

You're a living example of the above, step by step addressing the problem with an eye on the long term. I noticed the other day your plan all comes together in August as you get back to barbell work. How long did this process take in your case?

DanMartin
Shomer Shabbos
Posts 20705
DanMartin
04-09-06 03:53 PM - Post#199292    

Quote:

Laree said:
Oh, right! Forgot to mention I'd been doing that some at the gym.

You're a living example of the above, step by step addressing the problem with an eye on the long term. I noticed the other day your plan all comes together in August as you get back to barbell work. How long did this process take in your case?




Depending on perspective, either 3 years or two decades.
Mark it Zero.

Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
04-09-06 03:58 PM - Post#199293    

yikes.

Okay, I'll perseverse and quit griping.

ccrow
old hand
Posts 10055
ccrow
04-09-06 04:31 PM - Post#199294    

Laree, that post is very dense with information! I think I have been covering much of the same ground in parallel these past few years.

More and more I see the process as an incremental progression. For everything you want to do, there are prerequisites. For example you start out with back pain. Maybe it's severe and until you can get ahead of the pain you aren't going to get anywhere. For someone in this position of acute injury prescription drugs, muscle relaxers and pain killers, may be the only option.

Next you have to heal your spine's basic integrity. You can't do much with the muscles until the joints are at least somewhat sound. SO you wind up doing inversion, or on a traction table, doing Mackenzie exercises, etc. In the vast majority of cases, even according to orthopedic surgeons themselves, problems will resolve to a reasonable degree without surgery.

Once that's done, you can work on strengthening what's weak and stretching what's tight. This process can be sped up dramatically with some soft tissue therapy, whether it be the heavy artillery - active release therapy (ART) or the Graston technique, myofascial release or other deep tissue massage, or rolling around on a foam roller or a ball.

Knowing what's tight and what's weak can be pretty complicated. This is where the Escogue method left me high and dry. The book describes certain general postural conditions that cause problems for people. I am thinking I have a fair number of the problems of each, but don't fit any of Escogue's categories very well.

For an awful lot of people, a blind stab in the dark might not be a bad way to go. Stretch you hamstrings, calves, hip flexors, pectorals, lats, upper traps, and subscapularis. Strengthen your rhomboids, lower traps, external rotators, posterior chain (glutes especially), and your entire core.

There is a progression to stretching and strengthening too. The phenomenon of reciprocal inhibition is a huge factor; if you're tight on one side of the joint, you may get very little results trying to strengthen the opposite side. It seems to me that the first logical step is static stretching, then isolation exercises for remedial strengthening.

I think this is what was preventing me from getting the results I expected out of the prone "I" or "Y" exercise Laree describes. I was doing it and it was working a little at first but not much. When I stretched the antagonists - improved my pectoral flexibility - things really took off. For those of you who are bored to tears by this, my pathetic overhead strength is finally moving up as a result. :)

One thing I learned from this, close isn't good enough. I was stretching and strengthening ineffectively and getting little results. Start doing it effectively and bam, things really turned around.

The next step may be more complicated: taking basic strength and flexibility and turning it into useable strength and flexibility on the field and in daily life. There are special exercises that develop the neurological coordination that makes the stabilizers and the prime movers function together effectively - this is the basis of functional training. There are dynamic stretches, or should I call them mobility exercises, that develop strength and flexibility over a full range of motion.

(Some of these "special" exercises might not seem so special. The traditional straight legged situp, long reviled as unsafe and undesirable, can actually be a good exercise for training the deep abdominal muscles to stabilize the spine during hip flexion.)

At that point I think we've covered athletic performance but maybe not daily life. I am beginning to think it is easier to learn to overhead squat than to correct bad posture! I think it is Paul Chek that noted that dynamic mobility comes easier than static stability. I have been trying to learn more about the Alexander Technique, which I gather is basically a method of learning good posture and method for making it a habit. Here is an odd but interesting link on the Alexander Technique with some very good illustrations:

http://www.horseshoes.com/advice/prentice/cntwywr.htm

A lot of these things will overlap and intertwine but I think understanding the progressive nature is the key.

I have certainly blathered on here but this stuff is really important. Thanks for posting this Laree and I hope more will chime in. (Deston? Laird?) We have a lot of discussions about the best way to do preacher curls or what's a good superset for arms, which we all enjoy. But I think this type of information returns so much more because ultimately it isn't how you do your preacher curls, it's staying in the game that matters.
The most important test a lifter has to pass
is the test of time.
-Jon Cole

blondbomberhatman
At home here
Posts 167
blondbomberhatman
04-09-06 06:47 PM - Post#199295    

Maybe the pain in your body, if you do really have pain, is caused by the way you think. Maybe it is there because of the position you think you are in. Is there a way to think the pain away? Are you nervous? Ask yourself, when did you first notice the pain? Maybe it is caused by a bad experience in your life, and you have overlooked it, maybe have tried to ignore it. Are you in distress caused by the physical pain caused by your thoughtful position. Maybe to relieve the pain you need to change your thought position.

Just an idea. I want to relieve tha back pain.
Larry

Laird Scott
Settling in
Posts 59
Laird Scott
04-09-06 06:51 PM - Post#199296    

Recently, I mentioned that I had very restricted external rotation and that I thought it was a "natural" joint limitation. garyed and ccrow both disagreed with me, saying that I simply lacked flexibility. ccrow recommended stretching my pecs and my subscapularis.

Since I was already stretching my pecs, I decided to add ccrow's recommended subscapularis stretch:
http://www.exrx.net/Stretches/Subscapularis/Broomstick.html

I was skeptical, but started it. I could notice a minor increase in flexibility after the first day! I planned on waiting at least a month before reporting any results to the forum, because it had taken me several months to get my hamstrings stretched almost the way I wanted. But in less than one week I had gotten amazing results and PM'd Byron a brief thank-you.

In less than two weeks I'm able to hold an unloaded bar across my shoulders with no pain! I can reach up much higher when washing my back in the shower! My shoulders feel better in general! May I say YIPPEE!!!

For a broomstick, I used an aluminum shower curtain rod, which I eventually padded with foam where it crossed my arm. This subscapularis stretch has worked quickly and well. (Even though I've got quite a ways to go with it yet.)

Now, here's a coincidence. Before Laree started this thread, I couldn't help thinking that if a tight muscle had led me to believe that I had a restricted joint, why not other tight muscles doing bad things in other places? 26 years of leaning over an inspection bench had given me a forward-protruding head and an upper thoracic-slump. (Kyphosis, maybe?) If gravity induced it, maybe gravitiy could reverse it. So, I started laying back on a mat with my padded Top Squat beneath me. The handles make it easy to shift up and down my back for a series of one-minute gravity stretches. For variety, I use a foam cylinder which I cut from a child's pool toy. Already, it's slightly working. It's a little premature to say, but at 66 I may end up taller than I've been for a decade!

Laird
Bug
At home here
Posts 281
Bug
04-09-06 07:12 PM - Post#199297    

Laird for the last week or so I've been doing that broom stick stretch and the infraspinatus broom stick stretch for the internal rotation. I gave them a shot because they mimic the stretches the therapists were doing on me. Too soon to tell but I've had some relief the last two weeks and a jump in reps on my dips.
irondawg
iron claw
Posts 1999
irondawg
04-10-06 10:39 AM - Post#199298    

Swimming an hour a day going through all the strokes back and forth accross the pool is suppossed to be good for your back.
How often has bad management been mistaken for destiny?

Teresa
Sweaty girl
Posts 4427
Teresa
04-10-06 10:43 AM - Post#199299    

Quote:

ccrow said:
I am beginning to think it is easier to learn to overhead squat than to correct bad posture!





Ain't that the truth!

Laree, how have you found your backless computer chair? Do you feel your posture has improved since using it, if that was the intent?
"You will not be carrying around a scale to jump on and show people." - Vicki Masterson "The following time you better do more or you are dirt!" - Vicki again

Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
04-10-06 11:41 AM - Post#199300    

I like it, Teresa, and yes, it forces better posture. I've only had it a few days, though, and it takes some getting used to, both in habit and in using the support muscles. I still have my other chair handy, although I haven't had to pull it back around yet. Mostly, when I get tired and start slumping, I get up and do something else, including hit the floor for some stretches and roll the myofascial ball up and down the wall with my back. Then I go do something else that needs to be done standing up.

Deston Fallon
At home here
Posts 333
Deston Fallon
04-10-06 11:53 AM - Post#199301    

Laree . . . you are on to something here! I have been preaching for years and years that computers create a big weak hole between the shoulder blades (rhomboids) and act as a catalyst for lots of neck, back, shoulder problems and imbalances. If you sit slouched it is impossible to keep the ears lined up over the shoulders, much less back & down! Very interesting stuff you are posting here. I have my own thoughts as to why shoulder issues are so common.
Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
04-10-06 12:45 PM - Post#199302    

Deston, please add our thoughts! We can use this as a referral or jumpoff point for others later.

Teresa, I wanted to add that I bought a cheap chair, sort of on a lark. In hindsight, I might have figured out how to borrow one long enough to test it here at my desk, and then sprung for a nice Tempurpedic. :~)


cajinjohn
Old time trainer
Posts 12495
cajinjohn
04-10-06 12:59 PM - Post#199303    

That is why I always suggest working equaly for all parts including neck. I also have done hyperext. with weights for years. I also do real setups which a lot of people say doesn't work you abs. BS.
It don't matter

Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
04-10-06 02:08 PM - Post#199304    

Great addition, thanks. To recap, Byron said:

1
For example you start out with back pain. Maybe it's severe and until you can get ahead of the pain you aren't going to get anywhere. For someone in this position of acute injury prescription drugs, muscle relaxers and pain killers, may be the only option.

2
Next you have to heal your spine's basic integrity. You can't do much with the muscles until the joints are at least somewhat sound. SO you wind up doing inversion, or on a traction table, doing Mackenzie exercises, etc.

3
Once that's done, you can work on strengthening what's weak and stretching what's tight.

4
This process can be sped up dramatically with some soft tissue therapy, whether it be the heavy artillery - active release therapy (ART) or the Graston technique, myofascial release or other deep tissue massage, or rolling around on a foam roller or a ball.

Quote:


For those of you who are bored to tears by this, my pathetic overhead strength is finally moving up as a result. :)




HA! Good one, B.

Teresa
Sweaty girl
Posts 4427
Teresa
04-10-06 02:16 PM - Post#199305    

Laree, as backless office chairs go, that looks pretty sweet! I wondered about the "wheelability" of the first one. I see it has wheels, but I tend to scoot around a bit on my chair. Also, I like having the option of various adjustments for overall height but also for leg length.

One general question this whole thread has brought to mind. I'm fortunately not plagued with back or neck pain as a rule. But I do have a fair amount of shoulder tightness, especially just beyond the base of the neck. Would some/all of the posted suggestions help my shoulder issues?

In addition, my posture has been horrible for decades. I'm trying to be more mindful of good posture, and the tip that Ingrid posted a few weeks ago about standing with your arms down and turning the hands out was great. I try to do that a few times every day. I'm aware that good posture certainly can't hurt whether or not you have other issues, so that's something I'm striving for, but it's a struggle.
"You will not be carrying around a scale to jump on and show people." - Vicki Masterson "The following time you better do more or you are dirt!" - Vicki again

/sk
geek for "seldom posts"
Posts 4826
/sk
04-10-06 02:22 PM - Post#199306    

Quote:

Laree said:
I like it, Teresa, and yes, it forces better posture. I've only had it a few days, though, and it takes some getting used to, both in habit and in using the support muscles. I still have my other chair handy, although I haven't had to pull it back around yet. Mostly, when I get tired and start slumping, I get up and do something else, including hit the floor for some stretches and roll the myofascial ball up and down the wall with my back. Then I go do something else that needs to be done standing up.




Dancing?

/sk
Pot stirrer
Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
04-10-06 02:27 PM - Post#199307    

Quote:

Teresa said:
One general question this whole thread has brought to mind. I'm fortunately not plagued with back or neck pain as a rule. But I do have a fair amount of shoulder tightness, especially just beyond the base of the neck. Would some/all of the posted suggestions help my shoulder issues?




TERESA! Go after this one:

http://www.davedraper.com/forum/showflat.php?Cat=0&Board=Home&Number=60636

Cured my neck/shoulder aches (ignored for at least ten years) in under two weeks! I couldn't be happier about that part.

/sk
geek for "seldom posts"
Posts 4826
/sk
04-10-06 02:31 PM - Post#199308    

Quote:

Laree said:
Deston, please add our thoughts! We can use this as a referral or jumpoff point for others later.

Teresa, I wanted to add that I bought a cheap chair, sort of on a lark. In hindsight, I might have figured out how to borrow one long enough to test it here at my desk, and then sprung for a nice Tempurpedic. :~)






Consider a base for a fit ball. They are very comfortable.

/sk
Teresa
Sweaty girl
Posts 4427
Teresa
04-10-06 02:35 PM - Post#199309    

Quote:

Laree said:
TERESA! Go after this one:

http://www.davedraper.com/forum/showflat.php?Cat=0&Board=Home&Number=60636

Cured my neck/shoulder aches (ignored for at least ten years) in under two weeks! I couldn't be happier about that part.




Laree, in fact I tried that this weekend. I had a hard time isolating the spot in my back where I should be feeling it so I stopped. Also, where do you have your head? I tried it once with it completely off the bench, but I was generating too much tension just keeping my head up. Seems like something with a donut-hole opening like a chiro or massage table would be good, but what do you do with a regular bench?
"You will not be carrying around a scale to jump on and show people." - Vicki Masterson "The following time you better do more or you are dirt!" - Vicki again

Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
04-10-06 03:47 PM - Post#199310    

Both my head and feet are raised *slightly* off the bench. Not too much, just a couple of inches, and I only do sets of 8 reps at a time. It's torture, seriously -- very funny that something so light hurts so much. I guess it's an indication of how weak the muscle is and how much I needed the work.

I did have a hard time hitting the right spot, but I'll say again, it's worth the effort. Now I only do a couple sets once a week and it's enough to get the job done.

ccrow
old hand
Posts 10055
ccrow
04-10-06 05:44 PM - Post#199311    

Do you feel anything different doing it with your thumbs up?

I have been doing this on an incline board. I relax and let my forehead touch the board in the bottom position, then make an effort to arch my upper back and raise my chest off the board as my arms come up.

In just about any remedial exercise like this, if you can get someone to touch the muscles - just put their forefingers light on the muscles between the shoulderblades - it is easier to "find" them and make them work.
The most important test a lifter has to pass
is the test of time.
-Jon Cole

Topper
Settling in pretty good
Posts 72
Topper
04-17-06 07:47 AM - Post#199312    

I've been doing this new routine for about 8 weeks now, and like it.
OHP, SQUATS, FARMERS WALK, PULLOVERS AND CURLS...one major problem is my back started with this little twinge, which now is a major twinge. I took a week off again, went back yesterday and did my routine again. Geeezzzz, not sure if this pain is from OHP's or SQUATS. I don't have pain when doing these exercises, but boy the next day...yikes Does anyone have a ideas on replacements exercises or what am I doing wrong. I was really getting into those squats, but now I'm afraid to do them. And, now I have to take somemore time off cause the pain is baddddddd....Thanks. :)
theVeep
...through discipline
Posts 2004
theVeep
04-17-06 08:04 AM - Post#199313    

How heavy are you going? What are your rep/set schemes? How many days are yo working out? On which movements are you feeling pain? Are you wearing a belt?

There's a lot to look at ranging from form to using too much weight or just working out too much.

Lou


Andy Mitchell
Factus non verbis
Posts 5269
Andy Mitchell
04-17-06 08:30 AM - Post#199314    

Get it checked by a physio.
Describe the "twinge" is it a local pain or is there numbness, tingling, does the pain shoot down leg.
It could be just DOM's if not you should seek professional advice now!
Nice legs-shame about the face

Topper
Settling in pretty good
Posts 72
Topper
04-17-06 08:39 AM - Post#199315    

theteach....ohp 20#, 8x, 3sets, squats 5-6sets, the most weight I did was 74lbs plus the bar, 3 days a week, no belt, and I don't know which exercise is causing this...I think its the ohp and then the squats aggravates?? On the ohp, when I picked the bar up is when I feel that slight twinge, it does not go down my leg, and I think, well I know my hamstrings or very tight, I've been stretching them as much as I can.
bulch
pete
Posts 4276
bulch
04-17-06 09:06 AM - Post#199316    


Putting ice on it and taking ibuprofen should help with the pain but beyond that the may be something wrong with your form.
Best thread ever! :)

lucktree
Old hand here on IOL
Posts 890
lucktree
04-17-06 09:08 AM - Post#199317    

Hi Topper,
Re substitute exercises:
Instead of OHP try seated press behind neck;
Instead of SQUATS try hack or front squats;
Instead of FARMERS WALK try wrist curls and seated calf raise;
Instead of PULLOVERS try Nautilus pullovers;
Instead of CURLS try preacher curls.
Good luck.
Power is nothing without control!

mhess
Old hand here on IOL
Posts 749
mhess
04-17-06 01:24 PM - Post#199318    

Topper,

I have always had some lower back issues but last year I was in Pa on a weekend getaway and I could barely bend over to pick up my 1 year old daughter. When I got back home I was on this site and someone recommended "press ups" ( I think this is what they were called).
You lay on the ground face down and lift your upper body off the ground (pressing off with your hands) shoulders first while keeping your hips on the ground. Let's put it this way....the first time I tried it I could barely lay on the ground face down!! That's when I knew I had a problem. After one hour of slowly stretching and increasing my range of motion, I felt like a new man. Now I perform the stretch as part of my post workout routine.

Even on off days when I feel a little tight I'll lay down and strech it out and I always feel much better.

This may not be the solution to your problem but give it a shot.

Maybe someone knows the link to that old discussion from a year or so ago?

Good luck,
Mike
DanMartin
Shomer Shabbos
Posts 20705
DanMartin
04-17-06 01:29 PM - Post#199319    

Quote:

lucktree said:
Hi Topper,
Re substitute exercises:
Instead of OHP try seated press behind neck;
Instead of SQUATS try hack or front squats;
Instead of FARMERS WALK try wrist curls and seated calf raise;
Instead of PULLOVERS try Nautilus pullovers;
Instead of CURLS try preacher curls.
Good luck.





Whoa! Lets not go crazy.
Mark it Zero.

cajinjohn
Old time trainer
Posts 12495
cajinjohn
04-17-06 02:06 PM - Post#199320    

I looked and I looked I still don't see any direct back work to streangthen the area.
It don't matter

ingrid
Settling in pretty good
Posts 88
ingrid
04-17-06 02:32 PM - Post#199321    

It is extremely important when you have low back issues to work on core stabilization. This is the only thing that will directly strengthen that area so you have better natural support (as opposed to relying on a belt).

Core stab work is NOT ab training. These are mostly isometric holds, but can be done with small movements as well. Some simple exercises to start with are bridges, and both prone and side supports.

Bridges:
Lie on your back with your feet flat and knees bent. Lift your hips off the floor without arching your back - push through your glutes instead. Hold this position as long as you can, working up to 2 minute holds.

Prone supports (AKA planks):
Either on your elbows or hands and your toes, lift your whold body off the floor (in a push up position) holding your spine as neutral as possible. The hips should be aligned with the rest of your body. Again, work on holding this as long as possible.

Side supports:
Lie on your side propped up on your elbow. Lift your hips off the ground, keeping your entire body in a straight line. If possible, keep your top hand on your hip, but if you need to, you can use it for initial support on the ground.

You should include all these movements every day. If you have a hard time holding any of these for 30 seconds, then it is definitely an area you need to work on if you want to keep squatting, etc.

There are many variations (both more and less difficult as needed) that can be done on all of these. But start with these and see what kind of core strength you have now.
DanMartin
Shomer Shabbos
Posts 20705
DanMartin
04-17-06 02:49 PM - Post#199322    

Quote:

cajinjohn said:
I looked and I looked I still don't see any direct back work to streangthen the area.




Or even ab work.

I mean no disrespect, but something is wrong when such light weight brings you grief.
Mark it Zero.

pwrhngry
Carpal tunnel from posting!
Posts 2434
pwrhngry
04-17-06 07:48 PM - Post#199323    

Sounds like your core needs some attention. On the squats and ohp, if the internal obliques and transverse abdominus are weak it causes you to boww the lower back in (exessive lordosis) first off concentrate on keeping the hips from rolling back when doing them. Keep your butt right below your shoulders, pelvis forward, kind of. Like your squeezing the glutes together.
As to the core, Id do some roll outs, but againg, when doing them dont roll so far out that the lower back dips, and you go swaybacked. The point where this happens is the limit of the movement for you, just work oit farther and farther out.
An easy way to test your core strength at maintaining your hip girdle is to lie down on your back with your feet straight up. Then press the small of your back down to the deck, and begin to lower your legs, while keeping the lower back pressed down. If you cant make it to the floor with the feet, without the lower back arching up from the florr, then you have weak core muscles stabalizing the hips. You can use the test as an exercise to strengthen them. If you need to start with one leg at a time and work up. By the time you can "pass" the test your internal rectus abdominus, and tranverse abdominus will be strong enough to stabalize the lower back and hips during the big movements (OHP, squats, deads, powercleans)
Be well, and GOD bless,
Dave
God is interested in our character, not our comfort!...Me

"When your going through Hell, keep going."... W. Churchill

"May you be in heaven an hour before the devil knows your dead."...Irish proverb


Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
04-17-06 08:41 PM - Post#199324    

Quote:

mhess said:
I have always had some lower back issues but last year I was in Pa on a weekend getaway and I could barely bend over to pick up my 1 year old daughter. When I got back home I was on this site and someone recommended "press ups" ( I think this is what they were called).
You lay on the ground face down and lift your upper body off the ground (pressing off with your hands) shoulders first while keeping your hips on the ground. Let's put it this way....the first time I tried it I could barely lay on the ground face down!! That's when I knew I had a problem. After one hour of slowly stretching and increasing my range of motion, I felt like a new man. Now I perform the stretch as part of my post workout routine.

Maybe someone knows the link to that old discussion from a year or so ago?





Here are a couple of older low-back pain threads that discuss press ups.

http://www.davedraper.com/forum/showflat.php?Cat=0&Board=Home&Number=112997

http://www.davedraper.com/forum/showflat.php?Cat=0&Board=Home&Number=111080

And here's a link to the long back diagnosis/rehab post thread from last week, but I'm guessing that's overkill for what you're dealing with here.

http://www.davedraper.com/forum/showflat.php/Cat/0/Number/193055/an/0/page/2#193055

I like Ingrid's recommendations a lot and am going to add those to my back stretching regime.

Topper
Settling in pretty good
Posts 72
Topper
04-17-06 08:46 PM - Post#199325    

Thanks, I will give that I try...I do notice when I do that ab exercise, that my back does arch.
Topper
Settling in pretty good
Posts 72
Topper
04-17-06 09:25 PM - Post#199326    

Laree,

Thanks for those links, they were very helpful...:)
ingrid
Settling in pretty good
Posts 88
ingrid
04-17-06 11:40 PM - Post#199327    

Laree,

I have a long history of LBP, starting with SI instability and getting to degeneration/bulging/arthritis, etc. I mised 6 months of training completely in 2004 and until last summer still had major problems. Then in August, I added LONG core stability holds to my daily regimen, and viola....pain is greatly diminished.

I started with 30 second holds then went to 60s. I repeat holds continuously for 5-15 minutes of 30-60s each and it has been my saving grace. I have many many variations of these for when the basics become easy, so let me know if you ever need more!

Always remember that quality is of utmost performance, with emphasis on keeping a neutral spine!
/sk
geek for "seldom posts"
Posts 4826
/sk
04-18-06 05:50 AM - Post#199328    

Sounds like she is offering to add to the Wiki, Laree! Catch her before she runs away!

/sk
ccrow
old hand
Posts 10055
ccrow
04-18-06 06:15 AM - Post#199329    

Quote:

ingrid said:
I have many many variations of these for when the basics become easy, so let me know if you ever need more!




Ingrid is teasing. Of course we need more!
The most important test a lifter has to pass
is the test of time.
-Jon Cole

Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
04-18-06 11:46 AM - Post#199330    

Wow, Ingrid, I never would have guessed! Amazing.

I did these last night and again this morning, surprised at how hard they are... did maybe 30 seconds and was shaking at the end.

Jeff Martone's got a two-part instructional bridging workout written up:

http://www.tacticalathlete.com/bridgearticle.htm

http://www.tacticalathlete.com/bridge2.htm

ccrow
old hand
Posts 10055
ccrow
07-08-07 10:11 AM - Post#321226    

This article is pretty good and it challenges some dearly - held ideas about low back health:

http://www.sportsinjurybulletin.com/archive/low-back-pain -exercises.html
The most important test a lifter has to pass
is the test of time.
-Jon Cole

DanMartin
Shomer Shabbos
Posts 20705
DanMartin
07-08-07 10:21 AM - Post#321228    

A few things I have found to work for me:

1. One hand kettlebell swings
2. Abdominal vacuums
3. Walking
4. Foam roller work
5. Swiss ball work
6. Avoiding activities that are known causes of spinal irritation (not as easy as it looks)
7. Fish oil
8. Maintaining adequate hydration
Mark it Zero.

Wicked Willie
The mouth of the South
Posts 16864
Wicked Willie
07-08-07 10:53 AM - Post#321233    

Of all of Dan's points, maintaining adequate hydration is very important, as it affects the integrity of the discs (which are mainly water.)

The article was very interesting to say the least...somewhat iconoclastic, wouldn't you say?

Wicked
"I'm in good shape for the shape I'm in."

"Jesus said to him, I am the way, the truth, and the life:
no man comes to the Father, but by me." John 14:6

DanMartin
Shomer Shabbos
Posts 20705
DanMartin
07-08-07 11:54 AM - Post#321260    

9. Wait a bit upon waking before exercising. (A couple of hours, in fact.)
Mark it Zero.

Andy Mitchell
Factus non verbis
Posts 5269
Andy Mitchell
07-08-07 07:40 PM - Post#321366    

Thankyou for the link.
If it's correct about pelvic tilt, it will put a lot of podiatrists out of work, yet another new industry.
Nice legs-shame about the face

Yeti
abomination
Posts 6587
Yeti
07-08-07 07:57 PM - Post#321369    

  • DanMartin Said:
9. Wait a bit upon waking before exercising. (A couple of hours, in fact.)



That's a good one, taking swollen discs into account. Not that I ever have any desire to work out first thing in the morning, anyway
"When [defeat] comes, I won't even notice. I'll be too busy looking good."

Yeti
abomination
Posts 6587
Yeti
07-08-07 08:29 PM - Post#321382    

  • Andy Mitchell Said:
Thankyou for the link.
If it's correct about pelvic tilt, it will put a lot of podiatrists out of work, yet another new industry.



I wonder how thoroughly the Finnish researchers tested the link between leg-length disparity and low-back pain. I've had assymetric DOMS in the lumbar erectors after heavy deadlifts, particularly on the left side (and my left leg is a bit longer). If DOMS has any effect on the endurance of the low back muscles, I don't know, but assymetric fatigue probably isn't a good thing.

Doesn't strengthening the low back improve its endurance? As a teenager I would often get immobilizing pains whenever I hyperextended my back. Working the weighted hyperextension turned out to be the single most effective exercise for getting rid of the problem.

Since that article emphasizes the importance of isometric endurance, I'd like to recommend yoga or pilates as a means of improving back health. The poses/postures exercised are inherently isometric, so practicing them enough will improve core integrity if done properly.
"When [defeat] comes, I won't even notice. I'll be too busy looking good."

Marooned Mike
SgtTTTT
Posts 4169
Marooned Mike
07-09-07 01:04 AM - Post#321473    

Well, if you don't like the current "scientific" rationale, just wait a minute & another "scientific" study will show the old rationale to be mythical... & if you don't like the new "scientific" rationale, then just wait a minute &...

If you've found something that's working well for you, then that's about as "scientific" as you need to get... test any "new findings" using caution... & if it works for you, then add it to your arsenal... & if not, then dump it & move on...

...that's my 2-cents
2009 Motto: Thinking Positive, Being Positive
"Start out easy & don't compete against anyone but yourself." -- Steve Reeves
"...work up to the number of repetitions that you feel necessary to do the trick. Don't hold yourself down to any hidebound number of repetitions." -- George F. Jowett
"Weight training is successful when you perservere." -- Mike Dayton

f4tune81
At home here
Posts 251
f4tune81
07-09-07 05:39 AM - Post#321506    

In this study, participants with low incidence of low back pain could lie on a table with the upper body unsupported in the horizontal position for almost 1 minute. Does anyone know what % of the general population can even do that (I don't think i'll try it: I'm sure it would give me a whale of a backache!)
ccrow
old hand
Posts 10055
ccrow
07-09-07 09:24 AM - Post#321556    

This is the top position of a back extension. I don't know what percentage of the population could hold that position for a minute, given the sorry place that is currently "average," probably not a large percentage. But, I think that with very little effort, 90% could achieve that level of endurance.

When you see results like this, you don't have to discard everything you already know. That isn't scientific. These findings are useful, but you should be able to reconcile things we already know with these results.

Improving strength is one of the best ways to improve this type of endurance. Think about this. If you don't know a thing about their endurance levels, who do you think is going to be able to hold a 25 pound plate with straight arms at eye level the longest: a guy that benches 405, or a guy that benches 225? So that's reconciled.

Tight hamstrings were not the best statistical indicator, but that doesn't mean they aren't a big secondary factor. The tightness in the hamstrings directly increases the load on the spinal erectors. That means that with loose hams, the same person's isometric endurance is greater than it is with tight hams. I am surprised that the article didn't mention that. I wonder what would have happened if they looked at the combination of hamstring flexibility and isometric endurance as a statistical indicator. With modern statistical software this would be trivial. You could go back and look at the data now and do the calculations, but that would be one of those dreaded meta-analyses that have an undeserved rep for only being useful for distorting the truth.

As for leg length discrepancies, I know big ones are a real issue, but I sometimes chuckle about people sweating a 1/4" leg length discrepancy. This is like thinking your car will go out of alignment if the tires on the passenger side are inflated a little more than the tires on the driver side. In reality, your car is made to deal with much more than a 1/4" discrepancy from side to side without even straining. Roads are crested. Likewise, the floors we walk on, sidewalks, etc. are not perfectly level.

Chiropractors often do a "leg length check" that really checks lateral tilt of the pelvis more than actual leg length. Some talk like they've actually measured a structural difference between the legs, and invite you to visit 3x/week for life. This kind of length check really can't be done reliably without much more rigorous testing. But the lateral tilt of the pelvis they do find, is often more important anyway.

As for the straight legged situps etc. - note that the study looked at something very specific, the ratio of tension in the abdominals to compression in the spine. Think about that for a second. This is pretty much a statistical verification of the maxim, a perfectly safe exercise is usually perfectly useless. To do some of the harder exercises, you have to be properly prepared! The idea of isolating the abdominals for cosmetic purposes is a BAD ONE.
The most important test a lifter has to pass
is the test of time.
-Jon Cole

ingrid
Settling in pretty good
Posts 88
ingrid
07-09-07 12:29 PM - Post#321636    

I definitely found this to be true.

A few years ago, I had crippling back pain that arose from severe instability in my SI. I was in such pain that I knew I was done as an athlete and would even have to do something to live a normal life.

I had always included stability exercises in my training and I was capable of performing what I considered to be very difficult stability movements. However, I always did these for reps, so time under tension was not all that long. Obviously, this wasn't enough.

I started with prolotherapy treatments, which at least brought some relief and got me back into the competitive arena. But I finally found that the best rehab for me was to perform LONG stability holds. Very basic holds, no fancy stuff - mainly bridging, side and prone supports.

Even now, I still do 5 minutes of continuous holding, moving from one exercise to the next, before EVERY training session. I also include one session of 15 minutes of continuous holding at least once a week. My back hasn't felt this good in years!
Marooned Mike
SgtTTTT
Posts 4169
Marooned Mike
07-09-07 05:13 PM - Post#321739    

  • Marooned Mike Said:
...that's my 2-cents



Here's a penny more for thought:

Those who could go for over 58 seconds... what did they do to get to this point of back endurance (did they all practice this exercise, or did they all do different things, or nothing at all... were they laborers or couch-potatoes?).

Is performing this test often (as an exercise) recommended for promoting back-health, or is it merely just a test to guesstimate one's back-health?
2009 Motto: Thinking Positive, Being Positive
"Start out easy & don't compete against anyone but yourself." -- Steve Reeves
"...work up to the number of repetitions that you feel necessary to do the trick. Don't hold yourself down to any hidebound number of repetitions." -- George F. Jowett
"Weight training is successful when you perservere." -- Mike Dayton

Vicki
Carpal tunnel from posting!
Posts 8196
Vicki
07-09-07 06:03 PM - Post#321755    

I was able to go 70 seconds without really pushing myself. I believe I got to this point with my consistant core work which consists of things that sound like what Ingrid described. She says "bridging" (thus called in the Stuart McGill book) and I am wondering if that is the same as "planks." I also do "birddog" and a holding "crunch." All three of the moves I am doing are from the McGill book.



ccrow
old hand
Posts 10055
ccrow
07-09-07 06:41 PM - Post#321772    

The birddog is an excellent static endurance builder, because it lets you work one side at a time.

The article does recommend simply holding the position for time once a day as a preventative exercise.

This reminds me of something I read a long time ago. In the book "Heavyhands" Leo Schwartz mentions that a friend of his was a doctor for a coal mining camp way back when, and said for all the things that these guys had to deal with, he couldn't remember ever having to treat a backache.

The most important test a lifter has to pass
is the test of time.
-Jon Cole

Laree
(Rhymes with Marie)
Posts 26002
Laree
08-08-07 02:26 PM - Post#334215    

Just a quick update, mainly for the folks here who were too busy working at a computer to read this last year.

I'm still a long way from instinctively and always retaining good posture, especially when distracted at work or when hanging around with people (the times good posture is most needed), but at my last physical instead of shrinking into middle age, the marker was up three-quarters of an inch, up to a whopping five foot, three and a quarter.

As a 51-year-old female who began slumping in her early teens, most likely to hide an emerging chest, this is pretty excellent news. Attention to posture, torso stability and exercises to target unused back muscles should be a priority for all of us.

WillVT
Getting the hang of it
Posts 48
WillVT
05-05-08 05:36 PM - Post#439024    

Just found this thread today after reading about Lordosis over on StrongLifts. I have a desk job and do a LOT of sitting every day. My lower back seems more curved than it should be, my lower abs stick out a little bit, and I get back pain from only moderately long periods of standing. I'm pretty certain that I have Lordosis and I'm planning to add some of the exercises discussed in this thread to my routine in an attempt to balance out my core strength and straighten out my back. Thanks for all the great information, this site is an incredible resource!



Home

What's New | Weekly Columns | Weight Training Tips
General Nutrition | Draper History | Mag Cover Shots | Magazine Articles | Bodybuilding Q&A | Bomber Talk | Workout FAQs
Privacy Policy


Top